Overflowing Cups & Cones
If you're searching for a delightful getaway in Hillsdale, Michigan, look no further than Overflowing Cups & Cones, a charming café located conveniently at 214 S Broad St. This local gem is not just your average café; it offers a comprehensive array of mouthwatering options that cater to the cravings you didn't even know you had.
The menu at Overflowing Cups & Cones is extensive, ensuring that every visitor finds something to adore. Start off your meal with their crispy Cheese Sticks or the addictive Chili Cheese Fries—a heavenly combination that’s perfect for sharing (or keeping all to yourself!). With prices that won't break the bank, even the pickiest eaters will find the Fried Pickles or Mac & Cheese Wedges hard to resist.
But that's just the beginning! Make your way to their smooth, delicious Strawberry Banana Smoothie, a refreshing treat that’s ideal for any time of day. And for the kids, the Dirt Sundae and Chocolate Moose are sure to make their day—these adorable and creative creations will leave little ones grinning from ear to ear.
The ambiance at Overflowing Cups & Cones is equally inviting. Many patrons have pointed out how friendly the staff is, creating a warm and welcoming environment where you’re sure to feel right at home. The café features a delightful outdoor area, complete with picnic tables and a unique petting zoo that will captivate children and animal lovers alike. Picture yourself savouring a hearty meal while little ones giggle with glee, feeding the goats nearby—it's a slice of community charm that many cafés simply can't replicate.
Real customers sing praises for their experiences at Overflowing Cups & Cones. Emily Emens, a loyal patron, raves about their swift service and the outstanding chicken sandwich—always tender and juicy, paired perfectly with mozzarella sticks that burst with flavor. Brandon Alvarez complements their ice cream creations, which are highly competitive, and he emphasizes how generous the portions are.
Whether you’re passing through Hillsdale or seeking a local hotspot, Overflowing Cups & Cones is a destination that satisfies both the tummy and the soul. It’s where delicious food, refreshing drinks, and friendly faces meet to create a community gathering spot that welcomes everyone. Don’t miss out on the chance to experience this unique café; your taste buds will thank you!
- Cheeseburger BasketUS$9.50
- Cowboy Sammich BasketUS$9.00
- Chicken Parm BasketUS$11.00
- Chili Dog BasketUS$9.00
- Dirty Dale BasketUS$12.50
- Double EspressoUS$2.15
- LatteUS$3.85
- CappuccinoUS$3.85
- MochaUS$4.15
- Hot DogUS$1.75
- Chili DogUS$2.50
- Polish DogUS$2.50
- HamburgerUS$4.50
- CheeseburgerUS$5.00
- Cowboy SammichUS$5.40
- Pork BbqUS$4.50
- Chicken WingsUS$6.50
- Cheesy NachosUS$2.00
- Nacho GrandeUS$6.00
- Walkin' TacosUS$5.00
- Pulled Pork NachosUS$5.75
- Chicken Parm SammichUS$8.00
- Crispy Chicken SammichUS$4.85
- Pulled Pork Cheese Fries Or Tater TotsUS$5.75
- Bacon Ranch Chili Cheese FriesUS$5.75
- Chicken SaladUS$7.00
- Cup Of SoupUS$4.50
- Uplifted
- Bean Redeemed
- He-Brews
- Holy Grounds
- Pastors Cup
- New Beginning
- The Reformed
- Cup Of Grace
- Pure Joy
- Cheese SticksUS$4.25
- French FriesUS$2.50
- Cheese FriesUS$3.75
- Chili Cheese FriesUS$5.25
- Onion RingsUS$3.25
- MushroomsUS$3.50
- Mac & Cheese WedgesUS$4.50
- Fried PicklesUS$3.25
- Whole Dill PickleUS$1.50
- Cheese CurdsUS$3.25
- Strawberry Banana
- Classic Strawberry
- Blah,Blah, BlahUS$5.90
- Caramel AppleUS$5.70
- Chocolate Chip Cookie SupremeUS$5.95
- Dirty WindshieldUS$5.90
- EliminatorUS$5.90
- FingerliciousUS$5.70
- Hot Fudge BrownieUS$6.50
- Muddy PieUS$5.50
- Raspberry DelightUS$5.50
- SnowballUS$5.50
- Super Strawberry ShortcakeUS$6.50
- Ltimate Chocolate OverloadUS$5.90
- Imate Peanut Butter OverloadUS$5.90
- Berry MuffinatorUS$5.95
- Fruit ParfaitUS$5.50
- Peanut ParfaitUS$5.65
- Banana SplitUS$6.95
- Hot Fudge Banana RoyalUS$6.50
- Dirt SundaeUS$3.50
- Chocolate MooseUS$3.50
- Mini Chocolate CakeUS$3.50
- BombUS$3.50
- Little HeroesUS$3.60
- Tin Roof SundaeUS$3.65
- Turtle SundaeUS$4.30
- Dip-A-Dee-DooUS$1.85
- Frozen Banana On A StickUS$1.85
- Ice Cream SandwichUS$1.85
- Dreamy Cheesecake On A StickUS$2.50
- Egg Bake SammichUS$3.00
- Breakfast BurritoUS$3.00
- Biscuits & GravyUS$4.00
- Tots W/Gravy & CheeseUS$6.00
- The Mornin' MessUS$7.00
- The Mini Mornin' MessUS$5.00
- Toasted BagelUS$2.00
- Blueberry MuffinUS$2.50
- Cinnamon RollUS$2.50
- Mini DonutsUS$5.00
39 Reviews
11 Sep 2025
29 Aug 2025
21 Aug 2025
18 Aug 2025
20 Jul 2025
29 Jun 2025
Millers Artisan Cafe
El Encuentro Calle Real
Cherries Gaming Cafe
La Fragua Cafe Gourmet
Join the Overflowing Cups & Cones Newsletter
Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.